Sitemap
Enrique Dans

On the effects of technology and innovation on people, companies and society (writing in Spanish at since 2003)

Member-only story

Spain’s blackout: blaming renewables only reveals ignorance and conflicts of interest

--

IMAGE: A giant nuclear reactor, clumsily disguised with solar panels taped to its dome, and a banner reading, “I’m green too.” Beside it, a modern solar plant, connected to a stylized lightning bolt battery, regards the reactor with a mixture of bewilderment and condescension. The reactor sits atop a money bag bearing a power company logo, while the solar plant and battery float lightly on a cloud with a clean, green plug symbol. The caption reads, “When you can’t compete, blame the sun”

On April 28, . In a matter of minutes, generation fell by more than 15 GW, interconnections with France were interrupted, and much of the system was disconnected for safety reasons, leaving both countries without power for several hours.

The immediate reaction of some pundits and interested parties? . The level of misinformation was as grotesque as it was predictable: a media offensive that reveals more about the interests of those behind it than the reality of the electricity system.

Blaming the sun is energy flat-earthism. Renewables did not cause the blackout. Attributing the collapse to the fact that the system was running on more than 70% renewables is like blaming water for a bridge collapsing: it’s not the flow, it’s the structure.

The Spanish electricity grid’s design is 50-years old: for large thermal and nuclear power plants, with physical rotation and mechanical inertia.

The problem is not the presence of renewables, but the absence of the elements necessary to integrate them properly: storage, advanced electronics, and a regulatory architecture adapted to their nature.

Enrique Dans
Enrique Dans

Published in Enrique Dans

On the effects of technology and innovation on people, companies and society (writing in Spanish at since 2003)

Enrique Dans
Enrique Dans

Written by Enrique Dans

Professor of Innovation at IE Business School and blogger (in English here and in Spanish at )

Responses (20)