Member-only story
“What Do You Want Me To Say About Slavery?”
Why People Like Me Are Criticizing the A24 Civil War Movie
I don’t believe it’s possible to write a fictional account of America’s second civil war without alienating a segment of the audience. That, however, is what Alex Garland tried to do. Instead of exploring our culture and our social and political problems, Garland made a movie about war correspondents and their challenges in covering social issues.
By doing that, he exploits the county's insidious sense of menace to attract attention to a movie that is wrong about the dynamics that are leading to civil war in America.
In an interview with Audie Cornish, Garland laments the rise of populism in the UK, Israel, Europe, Asia, and South America.
Alex Garland
It’s not hard to find countries that have some kind of deep division which is represented, in their politics and in their population.
Some kind of deep division…
His movie is about a second civil war in America, so let’s examine one of the divisions to which he must be referring.
Guns
All I did was google the words ‘polling on guns,’ and here are just a few headlines that came up:
